Claire Mercer kept to a schedule the way some people keep to a liturgy. She arrived at the Department of Civic Data on most weekdays at 7:30, before the elevators filled with commerce-suited deputies and before the municipal fountain outside the glass atrium disgorged its early commuters. The records room on the third floor smelled faintly of toner and disinfectant; the hum of servers in the back was a steady, mechanical respiration that had soothed her through late nights and the low hum of grief. For twelve years she had treated the city’s paperwork like a ledger of lives—tax assessments, benefit registrations, housing transfers—each entry a trace of someone who had once depended on a system to remember them.
Today she was doing what she always did before an audit: sampling. Her palms left a residue on the laminated table as she sorted through the flagged indexes, eyes scanning for inconsistencies the algorithms didn’t catch. It was the kind of work that rewarded patience: a missing digit, a mismatched timestamp, a redaction that didn’t line up with protocol. Her colleagues called her obsessive. Her mother called it obsessive too, but also practical, a place to put the anxiety that had followed Claire since childhood—the absence of answers about her own family when the city had been kinder to development than to memory.
The flagged file that caught her attention was small and unremarkable at first glance: a routine housing assistance case for a woman named Samira Ortiz. Claire’s index showed Samira as a long-term recipient, low income, participant in a neighborhood stabilization program that the city touted at ribbon-cuttings. On-screen, the case looked like a thumbnail of a life, bureaucratic and ordinary: application dates, a benefit ID, notes. Then there was a redaction field—one of those blacked-out rectangles that meant something beyond error. The audit rules called for redactions to be annotated, signed, and cross-referenced. This one had a signature, but it was not the hash of an employee key she recognized.